a bit more info
Ben, a small bit of info that you might not know about me. I AM a Code Enforcement Officer for Columbus. Technically, WE are the ones who cite the things you talked about (Sheds, Sidewalks, grass, etc). I work with many HOA's, that's my job.
Now, a HOA can take a person to small claims court for a deed restricion violation. Remember this though. The HOA has to pay for court cost up front. Then, IF the HOA wins (which doesn't happen all that much) they can recoup that cost. Quite honestly, if the homeowner gets an attorney that knows what he is doing, the HOA will loose. When the City Cites something, it's not a deed restriction, but it's LAW! Everything we cite are criminal violaions. So, what I'm telling you and what I have told our HOA is that Deed Restrictions aren't worth the paper they are written on. I have tried to work with our HOA in the past. All my advice was taken in vain. If you check into it now, all the HOA does is write down stuff and calls the Code Officer for our area. In your past areas, the reason it gets like that is that homeowners arent' willing to call us or don't know to call us.
Another point. As far as sheds and stuff like that, the developer (MI) adds that stuff into the deeds incase homeowners try to build something while they are still in the community. So the developer will get paid for building anything. Above ground pools? Why would anybody have a problem with these. Thats just petty. As long as they are in good shape, who cares. Once again, Code Enforcement cites for rundown stuff. If there are commercial vehicles in the street, call the police. The code for that is 2151.21 and that vehicle can be in the street for no more than an hour. Same with trailers, campers, etc.
So, taking all that into account, the only thing left is the grass. Yea, it might not look as nice as you would want it. However, I'm not going to pay to have someones grass cut. Especially when I cite people for not cutting grass. See my point! Once again, that homeowner can have you arrested for trespassing.
Now, what does our HOA do? You tell me.